FREE TOOL

Follow-up ROI: does chasing unbooked leads pay for itself?

Plenty of leads don’t book on the first call. See what the ones you win back with follow-up are worth after you pay to run it.

By the BlueSmith team · Updated

At a glance

You enter
  • Leads per month that don’t book on first contact
  • Of those, how many follow-up turns into a booked estimate
  • Estimates you close
  • Average project value
  • Gross margin
  • Monthly cost of running follow-up
You get
  • Gross profit from follow-up per month
  • Extra booked estimates per month
  • Return on the follow-up cost
How the math works
  • Estimates follow-up brings back
  • Gross profit from them
  • Net gain and return
  • Example numbers, not a benchmark
What it costs
Free. No signup, no email. Arithmetic on your own numbers, not a promise of results.
15%
30%
35%

Gross profit from follow-up per month: $11,313

Gross profit from follow-up per month$11,313
Extra booked estimates per month
4.5
Return on the follow-up cost
2262.5%

30 unbooked leads, 15% recovered, 30% closed at $25,000 and 35% margin, $500 a month to run.

See what we’d build for these numbers

Starts with example numbers. Change them to yours. Arithmetic only, not a promise of results.

HOW IT WORKS

Three steps. Your numbers.

  1. 01

    Enter your numbers

    Enter the leads per month that don’t book on first contact.

  2. 02

    Watch it recalculate

    Add the share you expect follow-up to turn into booked estimates, your close rate, project value, margin, and monthly cost.

  3. 03

    Use the answer

    Check the net gain and return, then test a lower recovery rate to see where it stops paying.

How the math works

Estimates follow-up brings back

Unbooked leads × recovery rate. These are leads that only booked because someone kept reaching out.

Gross profit from them

Extra booked estimates × close rate × average project value × gross margin. Profit after materials and labor, not revenue.

Net gain and return

Gross profit − monthly follow-up cost gives the headline number. (Gross profit − cost) ÷ cost gives the return. If the cost is bigger, both go negative.

Example numbers, not a benchmark

20 unbooked leads, 10% recovered: 2 booked estimates. 25% close: 0.5 jobs. At $20,000 and a 30% margin, $3,000 gross profit. Minus $600 to run it: $2,400 net, a 400% return.

STRAIGHT ANSWERS

Questions we hear.

What recovery rate should I enter?

There’s no standard one. Track a month: of the leads that didn’t book on first contact, how many booked later after a text, call, or email? If you don’t follow up yet, start low and test.

What goes in the monthly cost?

Software and texting fees, the hours of whoever does the chasing at a fair rate, and any fee you pay someone to run it. Leave out ad spend; those leads are already paid for.

Can I keep texting leads who don’t answer?

Only if they agreed to get texts, and every message needs an opt-out like “Reply STOP to opt out.” Stop when they ask. A few spaced-out touches read as attentive; daily texts read as spam.

Does this cover old estimates that never signed?

No. It’s for new leads that never booked. Estimates you ran that went quiet are a separate pool, and following up on those is reactivation.

Numbers are the start. Let’s build the system.

Seven questions. Two minutes. See the one part of your engine holding your projects back.

Show me where I’m losing jobsFree 2-minute assessment · No pitch, no obligation

Avg response time 2.5 minutes